If you don't want any spoilers about SS, please stop reading now!!!
So I finally got around to finish Skyward Sword. Ironic that it took me so long since I got it like five days earlier than the whole of America and still three days earlier than the rest of Europe but a little while before the boss my interest just totally declined. So it collected metaphoric dust for a few months in my Wii until I picked it up again today.
First of all: When I finished off Demise I was like, what, seriously? That's it??? THAT was the epic boss of the game? I mean okay, he does indeed look pretty cool (like a weird mixture of Nosferatu Zodd from Berserk and Akuma from Street Fighter xD) but it's like they squeezed all the coolness that was missing from the rest of the bosses into this one instead of spreading it a bit more equally. And then he was easy as sh*t. I thought I didn't see correctly when the credits started because I kept hoping he'd jump out at me again so I could fight some more. But nothing.

And then the credits themselves, which started out very nicely with the retelling of Zelda's part of the story, became rather crappy through very choppy "camerawork".
All in all the game was a huge disappointment. Well okay, I shouldn't be all too hard on it. There were parts I really enjoyed like the overall dungeon design for instance. The Ancient Cistern alone was epic to no end and the same goes for both Fire Dungeons.
I also really liked the Ancient Harbour Area with the Skipper's Retreat etc. The atmosphere there was beyond awesome, I've rarely experienced such a sad and melancholic atmosphere in a game. The great music was the main thing that made this area into what it is.
Then the Silent Realms. Now THAT was cool stuff. I think I almost pissed my pants in the first one when the Guardians started to come for me and the light flared all threateningly.

But leaving all that aside, I don't have any special memories of the game. It's like it felt too bland to leave a big impression.
Apart from the giant annoyance that is Fi.
Seriously the game takes you for a complete retard. Not only because of Fi, also because of too many explanations in general. I mean wtf, so Ghirahim explains his ultimate move the last time you affront him so you know exactly how to avoid it??? That's a joke, right? /sad laugh
For me Skyward Sword does and probably always will rank lowest of all 3D Zeldas and even lower than some 2D ones.
I'm sorry if anyone disagrees with me, it's just my own opinion. If you disagree, well that's fine, I'll accept it, so please also accept my opinion and don't get rude.
From what I've played that you have talked about, I must agree xD
Fi is way too annoying. I found myself ignoring half of her calls because the game got me used to Fi saying "master, you have few hearts left, be sure to replenish your health" and "there might be a ?? persentage probability that Zelda might be here." Then when I've actually asked for help, she's never given me anything that actually helps me.
The best partner I've had from the few Zelda games I've played, has been Midna from Twilight Princess. She at least didn't speak as much, and had attacks of her own.
Another complain from me, is that a good amount of my time spent on that game is flying in the middle of nowhere on the back of that slow bird of mine.
The sky is mostly a bunch of little floating stones without much to see. I would have liked to see more that I could explore. Not really sure if it just feels that way to me, or if it actually has less places to explore on than other games. Not sure if I'm explaining it well.
Oh and I totally agree about the sky. It was sooo small, the vast and endless sky feeling totally didn't come up and it was indeed so empty.
I also think that there were way too little people living up in the sky. It seems...unlogical.
...sorry for my ranting, I just like talking about this stuff.
I agree with you, the story did feel very bland and superficial, it didn't feel as riveting as TP or MM at all...
I found Demise quite hard, though.
Uhm what else is there to say? Oh yeah Impa and the old woman being the same person was a great twist! I thought I'd hate Groose but I loved him by the end. SS Zelda was my favorite Zelda incarnation. Involved deeply within the plot, a typical, humble teenage girl personality was a nice change.
Although TP has Midna and better combat, I gotta give the edge to Skyward Sword.
But really, what was with SS's ending? T.T Zelda just says she wasn't to live there and Link smiles?! Is he gonna live there too? do they get together? What about Gaepora?!
Oh my sooooooo sorry for how long this is!
haha I totally grew to love Grosse too even though I found him very creepy in the beginning.
I just can't put it above TP though. ^^
TP just has this amazing atmosphere, so many great sidequests and minigames, the cinematic storyline, the freedom, etc etc.
So are Groose, Link and Zelda living down below? I can't explain why but I found that part of the ending a little sad.
And the Midna.
yup I also found it a little lazy that they left that so open. :/
Zant was okay as long as he was cool and mysterious but once he went all insane and psychotic...I dunno...
that took away the evil aura and simply made him a weird madman xD
Yeah I really didn't like that part of the ending. >.>
It was his bean head that ruined it all for me. A guy with that shape head cannot be a villain.
Oh I'm glad too they didn't add Ganon in this Zelda. That makes... hmmm I think 3 Zeldas without Ganon/Ganondorf ^^